Wednesday, November 13, 2013

Interview Protocol Questions. FIRST DRAFT

Interview Questions for undergraduate students who participate in religious activities at the Newman Center at UH Manoa. 

1.    I would like you to go back in time. Tell meabout religious activities you participated in before going to college (if there were any).
2.    When did you first decided to participate in religious activities at the Newman center?
     Supporting questions for question #2. Ask if the person does not give away all the information: 
      2a. How did you find out about the Newman Center and activities they provide?
      2b. What made you decide to join these activities?
3.    Could you describe your experiences of participating in religious activities. 
Additional probing question: How do these activities make you feel?
4.     What do you like most about the Newman Center activities? 
      Additional probing question:
      4a. What do you find most helpful/beneficial for you in the Newman Centeractivities?

Purpose Statement and Research Questions Update

The Purpose of the Research

The purpose of this study is to explore experiences of undergraduate students who engage in religious activities provided by the Newman Center at the University of Hawaii at Manoa. This study is aimed at understanding undergraduate students' perceptions of the role religious activities play in their lives and well-being. By providing a better insight into experiences of undergraduate students who participate in religious activities, I seek to legitimize allocation of resources to religious organizations and services on campus as well as encourage universities to provide more religious support to their students and design religious activities aimed at improving students' well-being.

The Research Questions
The study will be focused on the three major clusters of questions.
1)    What religious activities and support does the Neman Center provide students with?
2)    How do undergraduate students describe their experiences of engaging in religious activities at the Newman center? What do they find critical about these experiences?
3)    How do advisors describe undergraduate students' experiences with religious activities provided by the Newman center? What do they find critical about these experiences?

Memo on Validity

What I need to know
Why I need to know this
Kind of data that will answer the questions
Analysis plans
Validity threats
Possible strategies for dealing with  validity threats
What religious activities the Newman Center provides students with
If we are want to learn about students experiences with religious activities, we should know first of all what activities there are
Public records,



Interviewing
Information search and classification

transcribing
Incomplete, inaccurate or misleading information might be provided about current religious activities at the Newman center due to the lack of information contained in public records or lack of knowledge among  employees
comparison of the collected data from interviewing with data from public records

Undergraduate students experiences of engaging in religious activities at the Newman Center. What they find critical about these experiences.
We know little about undergraduate students perceptions of religious activities and roles they play in their lives 
Interviewing,
Participant observation
video taping, transcribing, coding, comparing coding with other coders, rereading, examining taking observations and video tapes into account
Students might feel as if they were being tested and give the answers they feel that are 'the right ones'

Student participation in religious activities might differ from day to day

Students' actions might be misinterpreted by the researcher
Conduct one-on-one interviews with students in order to eliminate potential pressure of being afraid of what their peers might think of them and their answers

Make sure students understand that there are no 'right' or 'wrong' answers, the researcher would like to know how they feel and what to know about their experiences, even though these experiences might be bad, strange or different from their peers experience; and this is fine.

long-term observation for more accurate data

extensive interviewing and checking with students in order to make sure my interpretations are correct

member checking, bringing an outsider to see if he/she would interpret data the same way
How advisors at the Newman Center describe undergraduate students experiences with activities/services provided by the Center. What they find critical about these experiences.
If we want to get a better insight into students experiences with religious activities, we should look at it from different perspectives
Interviewing
transcribing, coding, comparing coding with other coders, rereading
Advisors may exaggerate the role of religious activities in undergraduate students' lives in order to make their center look better in researcher's or to please their bosses
Triangulation - collecting data from both lower- and higher-level employees, one-on-one interviews, making sure participants understand that interviews are confidential and that no data will be included in the final write-up without their permission to do so.

if necessary become an intervener in order to establish rapport and help them understand that if they do not like something about the Newman Center, they can try to change it with the help of this research